New does not mean flawless. An independent inspection before closing is the last point at which the builder still has a reason to fix things.
New construction is not inspected because builders are careless. It is inspected because a finished building hides its own construction, municipal sign-off is not a quality inspection, and the moment your leverage is highest is the moment before you close.
Finish quality, door and window operation, fixture and appliance installation and function, visible mechanical and electrical work, grading and drainage at the exterior, and roof and flashing where safely accessible. Individually most items are minor. Collectively they are a punch list, and a punch list is far easier to enforce before closing than after.
Heating, cooling, ventilation and plumbing in a new building have often never been through a full cycle under real load. The inspection operates and observes what can safely be operated and documents installation conditions, which is where new-build problems usually originate rather than in component failure.
Flashing, drainage, grading, roof detailing and the transitions where materials meet. Water entry is the most common and most expensive class of new-construction defect, and the details that prevent it are also the details most likely to be rushed at the end of a project.
New York provides a statutory housing merchant implied warranty for new homes under General Business Law Article 36-B. Its structure is worth knowing before you close, because it determines how urgent a given finding is. For one year from the warranty date, the home is warranted to be free from defects due to a failure to have been constructed in a skillful manner. For two years, the plumbing, electrical, heating, cooling and ventilation systems are warranted against defects due to a failure to install them in a skillful manner. For six years, the home is warranted to be free from material defects. That structure means workmanship items have the shortest clock and are the ones most worth documenting early. A written, photographed inspection report dated before closing is far better evidence than a recollection eighteen months later.
A certificate of occupancy, temporary or final, records that a building satisfied the approvals required to be occupied. It is not a quality assessment, it does not cover finish work, and it does not represent anyone having walked the property on your behalf. A temporary certificate of occupancy in particular means outstanding items remain. Those two things get conflated constantly, and the gap between them is exactly the space an independent pre-closing inspection occupies.
The useful window is after substantial completion and before closing, while the builder still has both a contractual obligation and a financial incentive to resolve items. Book it far enough ahead that findings can be raised, addressed and re-checked before the closing date rather than raised on the day. If the builder offers a walkthrough of their own, that is worth attending, and it is not a substitute for an independent inspection, because the person conducting it is not working for you.
Gut renovations and conversions occupy a middle ground: new systems and finishes sitting inside an existing structure. They carry new-construction risk in the new work and older-building risk in whatever was retained, and the two are frequently not documented to the same standard. The inspection covers both, and the report distinguishes between them so you know which findings sit behind new work and which are inherited.
Municipal inspections confirm code approvals were obtained. The builder's own walkthrough is conducted by someone working for the builder. Neither is an independent assessment carried out for the buyer, which is what a pre-closing inspection is.
After substantial completion and before closing, with enough lead time that findings can be raised and re-checked before the closing date.
The report gives you documented, photographed evidence dated before closing, which is what your attorney needs in order to hold something back, negotiate, or raise it under the statutory warranty. Without the report it becomes your word against theirs.
Yes. Gut renovations and conversions carry new-construction risk in the new work and existing-building risk in what was kept, and the report separates the two.
Within 24 hours of the inspection, in writing, with photographs.